The recent Cleantech North America conference in San Diego provided a glimpse into the complex relationship between oil investors and the burgeoning field of climate tech. As attendees engaged in discussions about the future of clean technology, it was discussed that the landscape of the industry is not as straightforward as it may seem.
The conference, partially sponsored by Breakthrough Energy, a venture fund founded by Gates, brought together a diverse group of participants, including oil and gas companies, mining giants, and cleantech start-ups. The presence of major players from the fossil fuel industry raised questions about the role of oil investors in shaping the future of climate tech.
One notable aspect was the dialogue among investors discussing the challenges of gaining interest from large corporations, including oil and gas equipment manufacturers like Caterpillar. The practical difficulties of aligning big businesses with small cleantech start-ups were highlighted, emphasizing the complexities of fostering collaboration in an industry driven by diverse interests.
Climate advocates often view the tech world as a potential ally, appreciating the surge in investment since the signing of the Paris Agreement. However, sceptics argue that excessive focus on technological advancements may divert attention from essential government actions required to address the climate crisis effectively.
While the optimism surrounding climate tech is not unwarranted, the conference shed light on the nuanced dynamics at play. The lack of urgency in addressing the immediate climate threats, such as extreme weather events and rising temperatures, contrasted with the emphasis on long-term technological innovations. The disconnect between scientific timelines and corporate interests became apparent, raising concerns about the industry’s ability to address urgent climate challenges.
The conference’s diverse array of cleantech companies, from EV-charging apps to smart mining technologies, showcased the breadth of innovations under the umbrella of climate tech. However, the absence of a clear definition for “climate tech” and “cleantech” left room for ambiguity, making it challenging to assess the impact of these ventures on current emission reduction efforts.
The most intriguing aspect of the conference was the overt presence of fossil fuel companies, including representatives from BP, Chevron, and Saudi Aramco. This raised questions about the compatibility of cleantech goals with the interests of companies contributing significantly to climate change. The issue of fossil fuel money in cleantech investments became a focal point, with discussions revolving around the potential benefits and ethical considerations.
One case in point was Amogy, a Brooklyn-based ammonia company that secured funding from Saudi Aramco Energy Ventures. The company aims to contribute to the transportation industry’s net-zero emissions, highlighting the intricate ties between cleantech start-ups and oil investors. The pragmatic approach of seeking financial support, even from fossil fuel companies, underscored the challenges of establishing a cleantech economy without compromising on funding sources.
The climate tech landscape’s complexity became more apparent as the conference progressed. The emphasis on profit margins over scientific imperatives was evident in discussions that downplayed the feasibility of limiting warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius. The disparity in attention given to adaptation technologies, despite the consensus on exceeding the 1.5-degree target, raised questions about the industry’s priorities.
As the conference concluded with a sponsored happy hour, attendees unwinding in the Southern California sun reflected on the challenges and opportunities in the intersection of oil investors and climate tech. The juxtaposition of optimism for technological innovations with the sobering reality of climate urgency highlighted the delicate balance the industry must navigate in the years ahead. The conference served as a microcosm of the broader challenges facing climate tech, where the pursuit of innovation must align with the imperative to address immediate climate threats.
To stay informed about the climate industry explore our latest climate tech news.
Featured Image: Credit: Cleantech San Diego
